Clay Tiles vs. Cedar Shake Roof: Deciding on the right roofing material
Deciding on the right roofing material can be a daunting task for homeowners. Two popular choices are clay tiles and cedar shake roofs. Each has unique characteristics that make them suitable for different environments and personal preferences. This comprehensive guide will help you understand the nuances of both, focusing on cost, material, colors, weight, durability, weather impact, environmental impact, and regional suitability in the United States, particularly for South Florida.
Clay Tiles: Timeless Elegance with Durability
- Material and Colors: Clay tiles are known for their aesthetic appeal, often providing a Spanish or southwestern look. They are available in various colors, adding a unique touch to any home.
- Cost: On average, clay tile roofs cost between $15-30 per square foot installed, a price point higher than asphalt shingles.
- Durability and Maintenance: Clay tiles excel in longevity, with a potential lifespan of over 100 years. They are resistant to fire, mold, and termite damage. However, they can be prone to cracking and require professional installation due to their weight.
- Environmental Impact: Clay tiles are environmentally friendly, with the ability to be recycled at the end of their lifecycle.
- Regional Suitability: Clay tiles are well-suited for regions with high heat and humidity, like Florida, due to their insulation factor and ability to withstand harsh weather conditions.
Cedar Shake Roof: Rustic Charm Meets Modern Needs
- Material and Colors: Cedar shake roofs, often made of high-quality cedar wood, offer a rustic and traditional appearance. Their natural wood color adds a distinctive charm to homes.
- Cost: The material cost for cedar shake roofs ranges from $6,300 to $15,300 for a 1,700-square-foot roof. Including labor, the total cost can reach between $9,000 and $30,000.
- Durability and Maintenance: Cedar shake roofs have a life expectancy of around 30 years, extendable to over 50 years with proper maintenance. They are durable and can withstand high winds and hail but are susceptible to mold, mildew, and moss.
- Environmental Impact: Cedar shakes are eco-friendly due to their recyclability and compatibility with solar panels. However, the need for cutting down cedar trees for production may be a concern for some.
- Regional Suitability: Cedar shake roofs are best suited for warmer climates but require more maintenance in humid or rainy areas. They are not the ideal choice for locations with frequent cycles of freezing and thawing.
Roofing in South Florida: What Do Experts Recommend?
In South Florida, the climate is characterized by high heat and humidity, along with the potential for hurricane-force winds. The best roofing material for this region is tile roofing, particularly clay or concrete tiles. These materials do not absorb moisture and have high insulation properties, keeping homes cooler. Additionally, they are strong enough to withstand hurricane-force winds.
Time to Choose
When choosing between clay tiles and cedar shake roofs, consider factors like cost, durability, maintenance, environmental impact, and regional climate. For homeowners in South Florida, clay or concrete tile roofs are the recommended choice due to their durability in high heat and humidity and resistance to hurricane-force winds.